Dr. Phillips: 407-855-1000
Winter Park: 407-629-6020


11 Myths About Florida Workers Comp Insurance (That You Probably Believe)

11 Myths About Florida Workers Comp Insurance (That You Probably Believe)

You’ve heard of workers compensation. You (hopefully) have it. You may even have had employees who needed it when they were injured on the job. But there are also many myths and misinformation about Florida workers comp insurance that you might believe. Misinformation that could prevent you from protecting your business the way you need to.

As insurance brokers, our goal is to see everyone receiving the right amount of coverage for their property, person, and business. And—whether you work for or own a business—you need to know the truth about Florida workers comp insurance.


1. “Workers comp is too expensive.”

stack of pennies

For some reason, too many business owners think of workers’ comp insurance as a “luxury.” But this type of thinking can lead to disastrous results for their business.

For one thing, if your business is among those that are required by law to carry workers comp insurance, you will be faced with a Stop-Work Order and have to pay a fine if you are found to be in violation of the law. In many cases, the penalty plus the amount of lost income is much more than the cost of paying your workers comp insurance premiums. In addition to these penalties, you will also have to pay out of pocket if any employees injure themselves on the job.

Even if your business isn’t required to carry workers comp, it’s still better to have it. Workers comp insurance premiums are based partly on your payroll, and there are limits in place to prevent you from having to pay out the nose. What is “too expensive” is losing your business entirely because an injured employee decides to sue.

Going without workers comp just to “save a few bucks” isn’t worth it.


2. “Only large businesses need workers comp. My employees are only part-time (or related to me).”

Regardless of the size of your business, workers comp is always a good idea. (You can even get an “owner only” policy if you want.)

In fact, most states think workers comp is so important, that they require businesses to carry it. In Florida, your business’ industry will often determine whether you are mandated to carry it.

In the construction industry for example, you must have Florida workers comp insurance if you have one or more employees. For most other businesses (excluding agricultural businesses), you must have a workers comp policy if you have four or more employees, including part-timers. And yes, your family members count as employees.


3. “My employees’ jobs aren’t dangerous. I don’t need workers comp.”

coffee spilled on desk

There’s a misconception that construction sites, warehouses, and factories are the only locations that workplace injuries can happen. This is simply untrue. In fact, office workers are more than twice as likely to suffer a workplace injury than non-office workers.

Not only are office workers not given safety training (like construction workers are), there are often hidden dangers around the office. Employees trip and fall over office equipment, sprain their neck while cradling the phone, or even come to blows over a work-related dispute.

Injuries can happen anywhere.


4. “My employees are like family. They would never sue me.”

It’s a comforting thought (and it probably makes it more pleasant to go to work every day), but how confident are you that no situation exists to make your employee consider suing you? In a country where people have been known to sue or disown their own family members, no business can claim that they are “too much like family” to have a lawsuit on their hands.

I’m also willing to bet that this loyalty doesn’t extend to your employee’s actual family, who might sue you if a workplace injury proves fatal.

If you think of your employees as “just like family,” treat them like it! Give them the respect and consideration they deserve by making sure they will be provided for in the event they are injured on the job.


5. “I don’t need to carry workers comp. I’ll just pay for any injuries out of pocket.”

man turning pockets inside out

If you have only one or two employees, it might seem more tempting to “take your chances” and not carry Florida workers comp insurance. After all, what are the odds that your only employee will become injured on the job? And even if they do, their medical bills are bound to be less than the insurance premiums, right?

It sounds like a good idea in theory, but there are way too many ways that this situation could go wrong. After all, no one can prepare for accidents; that’s what makes them accidents. So what happens when your employee loses a limb or when they experience complications from the injury weeks, months, or years later?

You can’t predict which type of accident your employees are more likely to suffer from. In the end, having a workers comp insurance policy is the safer bet.


6. “I don’t have to carry workers comp insurance if I call my employees ‘independent contractors.'”

This is technically true. Independent contractors are not eligible for worker’s comp coverage. But your employee does not become an independent contractor just because you say she is. The definition of “independent contractor” is set by the IRS, and misclassifying an employee as an independent contractor can have serious consequences.

Not only is this practice illegal, it’s unfair to your employees and just morally wrong. What’s more is that if your independent contractors don’t carry and provide proof of their own worker’s compensation insurance, the responsibility falls back on you.

So not only could your uninsured independent contractors still sue you if they are injured on the job, your insurance company will also charge you a premium for your uninsured independent contractors when they audit your policy each year.


7. “I don’t have any employees, just subcontractors. I don’t need workers comp.”

Shoe stepping on a screw

In absolutely perfect circumstances, this scenario checks out. But when was the last time you heard an insurance broker rely on circumstances being perfect?

Subcontractors are responsible for providing their employees with workers comp, but if they don’t, you will be held responsible if any of the subcontractors’ employees has an injury.

Former Florida CFO Jeff Atwater recommends doing your own due diligence to determine if your subcontractors have a proper workers comp policy in place, but it would be a great idea to carry your own policy anyway.


8. “You can reduce the cost of workers comp insurance by reporting a lower payroll.”

Since workers comp premiums are based partly on your company’s payroll, some business owners (and insurance agents!) have gotten creative when it comes to saving money. By reporting a lower payroll amount, they are written policies at much lower rates.

We’ve talked about this (illegal) practice before. Not only will your deception be uncovered during the annual workers comp audit, you will have to pay a fine equal to “ten times the amount of the difference […] and reasonable attorney’s fees.” The fines, criminal charges, and lost income (since you will be forced to cease operations) of your lie could spell the end for your business.


9. “Most workers comp claims are fake.”

A study by the University of Michigan found that only 1-2% of workers comp claims are fake, so it’s unlikely that your employees are scamming you.

If you suspect that one of your employee’s is faking an injury, report the incident to the Bureau of Workers Compensation Fraud. Fraud is not just illegal, it causes everyone’s premiums to go up.


10. “My employees will ask for compensation for ‘pain and suffering’ and take advantage of me.”

hand out to receive money

No business owner likes to think that their employees are taking advantage of them. But when it comes to workers comp, this is simply impossible.

When you purchase Florida workers comp insurance through an insurance company, you pay your monthly premiums and…that’s it. Any workers comp claims that occur will be paid by your insurance company. (Think about it, if you had to pay for the claims, what would be the point of having insurance?)

What’s more, Florida law does not allow injured workers to collect payments for “pain and suffering”.


11. “The injured employee’s claim is paid, so my obligation is over.”

Not so fast! A workers comp claim being paid doesn’t necessarily mean that your employee is cleared for work. Your role as the boss is to monitor your employee’s recovery and safeguard their return to work from further injury.

By assuming that they are “back to normal” and putting them back into the job that injured them in the first place, you risk slowing, halting, or even reversing the recovery that’s happened so far. Instead, speak to your employee (after they have spoken with their doctor) to work out a plan for transitioning them back into their role. Perhaps they need to be on “desk duty” until their back completely heals or need to wear a wrist brace when typing.



Workers comp insurance isn’t a luxury, a way to scam you, or even just “a good idea.” It’s a way to protect your business from risk and, in some cases, it’s the law. By understanding what workers comp insurance is (and what it isn’t) you can protect your company and your employees so you can stay in business for a long time.

If you’re in need of a Florida workers comp insurance policy, call us today for your quotes. Our two offices are conveniently located to better serve you.





About the Author

Jason Levine

Jason received a Masters of Science & Management in Risk Management & Insurance from Florida State University. He has been with Harry Levine Insurance for 9 years and handles the leadership of daily operations. He was the 2013-2014 Florida Association of Insurance Agents Young Agent Council's Agent of the Year. Currently serves on FAIA Board of Directors.